Zero-based budgeting: give every dollar a job
Updated
Zero-based budgeting means giving every dollar of your pay a job before you spend it, until the amount left without a job is zero. It doesn’t mean spending everything. Savings, a buffer and next year’s bills all count as jobs.
The idea started in business. Peter Pyhrr developed zero-based budgeting at Texas Instruments in the 1970s, as a way of justifying every dollar of a budget from scratch each year (Wikipedia). For a household, it works the same way, just every payday.
How zero-based budgeting works
- Start with this pay. The amount that actually arrives, after tax.
- Give every dollar a job. Bills, groceries, fuel, savings, the fun stuff.
- Keep going until nothing’s left without a job. If there’s money left over, give it one, even if the job is “buffer”.
- Do it again next pay.
The difference from most budgets is the last line: pay minus every job = $0. Nothing drifts in an account waiting to be spent by accident.
An example
Example figures only, for a household with $4,000 a fortnight after tax.
| Job | This fortnight |
|---|---|
| Bills (rent, power, phone, the big yearly ones) | $1,450 |
| Everyday spending (groceries, fuel) | $1,200 |
| Car (rego, insurance, servicing) | $300 |
| Savings | $600 |
| Fun money | $250 |
| Christmas | $200 |
| Total | $4,000 |
| Left without a job | $0 |
Zero-based budgeting, envelopes and buckets
You might know the same idea by another name:
- Envelope budgeting: cash in labelled envelopes, one per job.
- Buckets: separate accounts, each with a purpose.
- Pots: what Thrifty Pig calls them. A pot is somewhere money waits until it’s needed, a bank account or cash.
They’re the same principle: every dollar is somewhere with a purpose. The difference is only where the money physically sits.
Where zero-based budgets go wrong
1. The big bills get an average, not a plan. Giving the car $300 a fortnight feels like a job well assigned. But if the rego and insurance are both due next month, the right amount this pay might be much more. A zero-based budget can balance to the cent and still come up short on the day a big bill lands.
Example figures only: if $2,000 of car bills are due in three pays and the car pot has $800, it needs $400 a pay for those three pays, not $300.
2. It’s a lot of work every payday. Working out every job, every pay, takes time, and it’s the reason a lot of zero-based budgets stop after a few months.
3. No room for surprises. If every dollar has a job and something unexpected comes up, the money has to come from another job. That’s fine if you’ve given some dollars the job of “buffer”.
Doing it without redoing it every pay
The work in zero-based budgeting is the same each payday: look at every bill, check when it’s due, decide how much each pot needs this time. That’s arithmetic, and it can be done once and repeated.
Thrifty Pig does that part. You set up your pots, add your pay and bills with their real due dates, and it tells you exactly what to move into each pot every payday, including the extra when a big bill is close. Anything left over is swept somewhere deliberate, so every dollar still has a job. You set the transfers up at your bank once.
Common questions
What is zero-based budgeting?
A way of budgeting where every dollar of your pay is given a job, such as bills, groceries, savings or a buffer, until the amount left without a job is zero. It doesn’t mean spending everything: saving is a job too.
Who invented zero-based budgeting?
Peter Pyhrr developed it at Texas Instruments in the 1970s, for company budgets. Households later adopted the same idea for their pay.
Is zero-based budgeting the same as envelope budgeting?
They share the same principle: every dollar has a place and a purpose. Envelope budgeting is one way to do it, with cash in labelled envelopes. Separate accounts, buckets or pots are others.
Does zero-based budgeting mean I have no money left?
No. It means no money is left without a job. Savings, a buffer and money for next year’s bills are all jobs.
How do I handle yearly bills in a zero-based budget?
Give each one a job every pay, and base the amount on when it’s due, not just its yearly cost. A bill due soon needs more each pay than its yearly average. The calculator works that out for one bill. Open the calculator
Want every dollar to have a job, without redoing it every pay?
Thrifty Pig works out what to move into each pot every payday. Free for 30 days, no card needed.